The Price You See Isn't the Price I See
Is it time to dump your loyalty program?
On November 11, PBS News Hour aired a segment by economics correspondent Paul Solman (love him for taking one topic and enhancing the understand on it) on how companies are using AI and personal data to set prices. If you have ever wondered why the price you see might not be the price your neighbor sees, it is worth watching. Here is what stood out to me, and what it means for the way you book travel.
Same cart, different prices
The segment opens with an experiment. Researchers from the consumer group Groundwork Collaborative, working with Consumer Reports and More Perfect Union, had 400 shoppers buy the same 20 items from the same stores on Instacart and screenshot their carts. About three out of four items were offered at different prices to different shoppers, in the same pickup location, at the same time. Some gaps reached 23 percent. Instacart stopped the test after it became public.
Then the PBS team ran their own test. Several people ordered the same fast-food meal from the same restaurant, to the same address, at the same moment, through a delivery app. The meal cost the same for everyone. The totals did not: they ranged from about $18 to more than $22. The part that changed was the app's own delivery fee, its cut.
Travel came up too. Groundwork's Lindsay Owens described a case where a major booking site showed higher prices for the same Manhattan hotel room to people browsing from wealthier areas.
Where the data comes from
According to Owens, companies can learn a lot before you ever click "buy": your location from where you log on, your purchase history from a loyalty card or app, and guesses about who you are and what you earn.
That is where rewards programs come in. One of her tips surprised me: some shoppers have found better prices when they were not logged in to their loyalty account. Her explanation was simple. When a company knows your habits well, it may decide you will buy anyway.
What feels fair
Owens made a point I keep coming back to. Prices used to be tied to what something actually cost to make, and then, in her words: "Add a fair margin on top, put a sticker on it."
Most people still want that. The segment noted that more than 80 percent of Americans believe businesses should charge everyone the same price for the same item. Nobel laureate economist Richard Thaler, whose fairness research the segment revisited, said that companies caught pricing unfairly will pay a price of their own. Whether it will be enough to make them stop is another question.
Time to rethink your rewards program
I am not telling you to cut up every loyalty card. Some perks are real. But points can quietly keep you from comparing, and comparing is the one power you still have. A few habits, inspired by the segment:
- Check the price logged in and logged out. If logging in costs you more, your points are not free.
- Compare across channels. App, website and in-store prices can differ.
- Ask someone else to look. The PBS segment suggested you and your spouse both check before booking flights, and go with the lower price.
- Look at the final total, not the headline price. Fees are where prices move.
Full disclosure: what we do at Kinsona
I run a hotel booking site, so you should know where I stand.
The delivery-app test showed the platform's cut moving from person to person. At Kinsona, our cut is written on the receipt. Every booking shows three lines before you pay: the room total, a $0.50 platform fee, and the Kinsona fee. Our fee follows one formula, the same for everyone, and we do not use your personal data to set it.
To be honest about the limits: we do not set room prices. They come from hotels through our supplier and change with dates and demand. And yes, you sign in to see prices on Kinsona. That is because hotels set rules about where their prices can be shown, not so we can study you.
We haven't found another travel site that shows its cut on every booking. That is the whole idea: what the room costs, plus our fee. You see both.
Sources and credits
- PBS News Hour, "How companies are using AI to make you spend more money," reported by Paul Solman and Diane Lincoln Estes, November 11, 2026.
- Lindsay Owens and Elizabeth Pancotti, Groundwork Collaborative, interviewed in the segment. Owens' book Gouged expands on this work.
- The Instacart pricing study was conducted by Groundwork Collaborative with Consumer Reports and More Perfect Union, as described in the segment.
- Richard Thaler, University of Chicago, interviewed in the segment on consumer views of pricing fairness.
- All figures and examples above are as reported in the PBS segment.
Kinsona shows what we earn on every booking. See a sample receipt →